Skip to content
Mon - Fri 9am - 4pm EDT
877.863.5431
Help
My Account
Wishlist
0
Facebook-f
Instagram
Tiktok
Search
×
Dog
DOG CHEWS & TREATS
Bones
Bully Sticks & Holders
Cheek Rolls & Chips
Collagen Chews & Treats
Crunchy Chews & Treats
Dog Dental Chews
Elk Antlers
Freeze-Dried Dog Treats
Holiday Treats
Jerky Treats
Made in USA Chews & Treats
Natural Chews
Rawhide Alternatives
Rawhide Chews
Soft Chews & Treats
Training Treats
Yak Chews
VIEW ALL
DOG FOOD
Dry Food
Toppers
VIEW ALL
DOG TOYS
Chew Toys
Durable Toys
Fetch Toys
Holiday Toys
Interactive Toys
Made in USA Toys
Plush Toys
Rope & Tug Toys
Treat Dispensing Toys
VIEW ALL
MORE DOG SUPPLIES
Beds
Bowls & Feeders
Calming Aids
Grooming Supplies
Natural Flea and Tick
Poop Bags
VIEW ALL
Cat
CAT TREATS
Crunchy Treats
Dental Chews
Freeze Dried Treats
Holiday Treats
Lickable Treats
Made in USA Treats
Soft & Chewy Treats
VIEW ALL
CAT TOYS
Balls & Chasers
Catnip Toys
Holiday Toys
Silvervine Toys
Plush & Mice Toys
Made in USA Toys
Teasers & Wands
Treat Dispensing Toys
Wool Toys
VIEW ALL
MORE CAT SUPPLIES
Bowls & Feeders
Calming Aids
Grooming Supplies
Natural Flea & Tick
VIEW ALL
Made in USA
Brands
Holiday
Just In
DEALS
Gift Cards
About Us
My account
Wishlist
Need Help? Contact Us!
Checkout
X
Search
×
HAPPY NEW YEAR
10% OFF
- CODE:
YEAR2026
Get
10% OFF
Your First Order – SIGN UP for Email Deals!
Checkout
0
HAPPY NEW YEAR
10% OFF
- CODE:
YEAR2026
Get
10% OFF
Your First Order – SIGN UP for Email Deals!
SORT & FILTER
Default sorting
By title: alphabetical
By title: reverse
By date: oldest first
By date: newest first
Sort by price: low to high
Sort by price: high to low
Filtered (2)
Filters
Reset all
×
Promotions
×
Price
Brands
Mutts and Mittens
(
2
)
Categories
Cat
(
38
)
Cat Toys
(
38
)
Balls & Chasers
(
5
)
Catnip Toys
(
27
)
Holiday Toys
(
38
)
Made in USA Toys
(
14
)
Plush & Mice Toys
(
11
)
Silvervine Toys
(
2
)
Teasers & Wands
(
4
)
Wool Toys
(
6
)
DEALS
(
21
)
Dog
(
1
)
Dog Toys
(
1
)
Holiday
(
20
)
Just In!
(
5
)
New Cat Items
(
5
)
Made in USA
(
14
)
Cat Toys
(
14
)
Promotions
(
2
)
Mutts & Mittens
(
2
)
Show
(
2
)
Cancel
Holiday Cat Toys
Mutts & Mittens Heart Plush Catnip Toy
$
3.95
Mutts & Mittens Heart Plush Catnip Toy quantity
Add to cart
View Product
Mutts and Mittens Mitten Plush Catnip Toy
$
3.95
Mutts and Mittens Mitten Plush Catnip Toy quantity
Add to cart
View Product
More Holiday themed cat toys are arriving soon!
Reset all
×
Promotions
×
0
